PDA

View Full Version : Please remove RPG Up from your affilitates: it is a plagiarist site


Deep Throat
Feb 04 2007, 04:18 PM
I humbly ask the webmaster of this site to remove RPG Up and all "...-Up" sites from their list of affiliates. I ask this because these sites are heavy plagiaristic in nature, they take all the contents they can from the web and put it on their sites. They sometimes go as far as grossly removing the author names from the files they steal, while most often Disclaimers are still clearly written and clearly say the FAQ can't be used in the way the site use them.

Even worse, some of their files are pure illegal contents (mp3s, ROMs, the entire RPG Makers collection, etc.).

These websites, all owned by "PalSys System", do not deserve your support. Please avoid them and spread the news everywhere you can so that people can know the truth. Here's a list of some of their plagiarized contents (this list is by no mean complete!):

Articles

http://www.rpgup.com/evolution_therpg.php
Plagiarized from RPG Evolution (mhilluf@yahoo.com) (http://iml.jou.ufl.edu/projects/Spring05/Hill/rpg.html)

A lot of other articles are also plagiarized in the other "...-Up" websites (for instance there's a huge one in their BeforeCrisis website, in which the author put a lot of efforts to make something analytic, and then he's plagiarized and his name mentioned nowhere).


Game Manuals

http://www.rpgup.com/games/dragon_warrior/files/manual.txt
Plagiarized from Dragon Warrior - Dan Gonzalez (elendil@surfnetinc.com) (http://www.woodus.com/den/games/dw1nes/)

http://www.rpgup.com/games/dragon_warrior/files/manual.pdf
Stolen from Dragon Warrior (PDF) - Dragon's Den (http://www.woodus.com/den/games/dw1nes/)

http://www.rpgup.com/games/dragon_warrior_ii/files/manual.txt
Plagiarized from Dragon Warrior II - Christopher Lee Boger (leslumens@yahoo.com) (http://darken.0catch.com/goblin/manuals/manuals.htm)

http://www.rpgup.com/games/dragon_warrior_iii/files/manual.txt
Plagiarized from Dragon Warrior III - Kevin Falkowski (http://www.woodus.com/den/games/dw3nes/)

http://www.rpgup.com/games/dragon_warrior_iii/files/manual.pdf
Stolen from Dragon Warrior III (PDF) - Dragon's Den (http://www.woodus.com/den/games/dw3nes/)

http://www.rpgup.com/games/dragon_warrior_iv/files/manual.txt
Plagiarizef from Dragon Warrior IV - Dan Gonzalez (elendil@surfnetinc.com) (http://www.woodus.com/den/games/dw4nes/)

http://www.rpgup.com/games/dragon_warrior_iv/files/manual.pdf
Stolen from Dragon Warrior IV - Dragon's Den (http://www.woodus.com/den/games/dw4nes/)


Game Scripts

http://www.rpgup.com/games/chrono_cross/files/script.txt
From Chrono Cross - Sheamon (cain@xenogears.org) (http://www.gamefaqs.com/console/psx/game/196917.html)

http://www.rpgup.com/games/ffiv/files/script_gba.txt
From Final Fantasy V - Apathetic Aardvark (sinenomine@gmail.com) (http://www.gamefaqs.com/console/snes/game/588331.html)

http://www.rpgup.com/games/ffvii/files/script.txt
http://www.rpgup.com/games/ffviii/files/script.txt
http://www.rpgup.com/games/ffix/files/script.txt
http://www.rpgup.com/games/ffx/files/script.txt
http://www.rpgup.com/games/ffx2/files/script.txt
All from Final Fantasy VII, VIII, IX, X, X-2 - Oliver Kong (oliverkongsq@hotmail.com) (http://www.gamefaqs.com/features/recognition/6570.html?type=1)

http://www.rpgup.com/games/ffxii/files/script.txt
From Final Fantasy XII - piecemealcranky (piece_meal_cranky@yahoo.com) (http://www.gamefaqs.com/console/ps2/game/459841.html)

http://www.rpgup.com/games/ffmq/files/script.txt
From Final Fantasy Mystic Quest - Timothy Johnson (bobvila_16@yahoo.com) (http://www.gamefaqs.com/console/snes/game/532476.html)

http://www.rpgup.com/games/fft/files/script.txt
From Final Fantasy Tactics - Tsogtsaihan Baatar (Tsogtoo777@yahoo.com) (http://www.gamefaqs.com/console/psx/game/197339.html)

http://www.rpgup.com/games/ffta/files/script.txt
From Final Fantasy Tactics Advance - Lorenzo Rice (baralai614@hotmail.com) (http://www.gamefaqs.com/portable/gbadvance/game/560436.html)


Guitar Tabs

http://www.rpgup.com/games/ffi/sheets.php
From Final Fantasy - Magnus Andersson (magnus@guitartricks.com) (http://fly.to/nestabs/)

http://www.rpgup.com/games/ffii/sheets.php
http://www.rpgup.com/games/ffiv/sheets.php
http://www.rpgup.com/games/ffv/sheets.php
http://www.rpgup.com/games/ffxi/sheets.php
All from Final Fantasy II, IV, V, XI - Arnold Morrison (MrDoofus@hotmail.com) (http://www.nobuouematsu.com)


Thank you for your attention.

Fenristh
Feb 04 2007, 06:10 PM
Lol, looks like they do plagiarize.

Kitmitsu will probably look into this. Just a question though; what does it matter to you if Finalfantasy-xiii.net is affiliated with RPGUP?

Just wondering why you would go to the trouble of finding so many links and stuff to prove your point...

Enedok
Feb 04 2007, 06:26 PM
Kitmitsu will probably look into this. Just a question though; what does it matter to you if Finalfantasy-xiii.net is affiliated with RPGUP?

Just wondering why you would go to the trouble of finding so many links and stuff to prove your point...

I think its called revenge. And who can blame him for that. I would have done the same since they have plagiarized so much work.

Deep Throat
Feb 04 2007, 07:20 PM
I know some of the original authors of these FAQs, and I just hate plagiarism... Moreover, this RPG Up has mp3 soundtracks, ROMs, and the entire RPG Maker software collection available for free download... I wouldn't want anyone (except the site owner) to be in trouble if Square Enix, Enterbrain or other companies would find out these illegal contents.

Kitmitsu
Feb 04 2007, 09:59 PM
I've looked into the situation and it does seem that much of the content you pointed out is plagerised from other authors. I will remove the link from my affiliates however in future email the administrator of the affiliate instead of posting on their forums. Theres no reason for the whole community to know about it.

Nice job with the name Informant.

*Closed*